These companies have been around for years, have real reviews, and treat you kindly on the worst day of your life:
Pet Cremation of Bronx — petcremationofbronx.com
Family-run, known for gentle home pickup and clear pricing.
Pet Cremation of NYC — petcremationofnyc.com
Covers all 5 boroughs, no hidden fees, respectful staff.
Pet Cremation United — petcremationunited.com
Good option if you want same-day pickup and flexible payment.
Forever With You Pet Cremation — foreverwithyoupetcremation.com
Known for beautiful wooden urns and keepsake paw prints.
Gentle for small pets too (birds, rabbits).
Eternal Paws Pet Cremation — eternalpawspetcremation.com
Has great reviews for customer service and clear tracking.
Forever Friends Pet Cremation United — foreverfriendspetcremationunited.com
Offers family memorial options and personalized service.
What Makes a Good Pet Cremation Company?
✅ Clear: They tell you exactly what’s included — pickup, urn, paw print, timeline.
✅ Private: They guarantee individual cremation only, not communal.
✅ Transparent: No hidden fees.
✅ 5-Star Reviews: Check Google, Yelp, or trusted local sites.
How Much Should You Pay?
💵 Average NYC range: $700–$1400 for private, individual cremation.
✔️ Includes pickup, cremation, urn or box, certificate, and ashes returned in 5–8 business days.
Key Takeaways — Choosing the Right Company
✅ Always ask: Is my pet cremated alone?
✅ Read reviews. Call and listen to how they talk to you — they should be kind and clear.
✅ Make sure you understand pickup, timing, and what you’ll get back.
✅ Never go with the cheapest option that mixes pets — this is the time to spend for dignity.
This is my real list of trusted NYC pet cremation companies — so you don’t have to feel lost when your beloved pet crosses the rainbow bridge.